The People's Hammer

“Unions Will Bankrupt the Business” – By Bessy

,


Some people say this, but Lenin says this:

“…Taken by themselves, these strikes were simply trade union struggles, not yet Social Democratic struggles. They marked the awakening antagonisms between workers and employers; but the workers, were not, and could not be, conscious of the irreconcilable antagonism of their interests to the whole of the modern political and social system, i.e., theirs was not yet Social-Democratic consciousness. In this sense, the strikes of the nineties, despite the enormous progress they represented as compared with the “revolts”, remained a purely spontaneous movement.”

“We have said that there could not have been Social-Democratic consciousness among the workers. It would have to be brought to them from without. The history of all countries shows that the working class, exclusively by its own effort, is able to develop only trade union consciousness, i.e., the conviction that it is necessary to combine in unions, fight the employers, and strive to compel the government to pass necessary labour legislation, etc.[2] [my emphasis]”i

The argument of “unions will bankrupt the business” from workers who are employed by small businesses has come up on a few occasions. One time from one of my own coworkers, and a second time from a former barista from a cafe that closed during their round of contract negotiations. It is a fear imposed on many workers by the constant complaints and threats of small business owners that “business is tight right now,” “we are going through a difficult time,” or “we are not doing so well.” Obviously this represents the interest of the employer and small to medium bourgeoisie. However, this opinion has landed in the laps of workers who hear these complaints and become concerned about their own employment stability.

The size of small businesses in Canada is overwhelming. The small and middle bourgeoisie make a large amount of private sector business in Canada, and both the main political parties are avid evangelists of this sector of the bourgeoisie. For context:

“Despite representing 98% of Canadian businesses and employing two-thirds of the Canadian economy, the portrait of small business remains largely murky. In this report, BDL [Business Data Lab] created three more detailed subcategories of small businesses (micro, scale and mature), revealing that the experiences of small businesses vary significantly.

  • Micro: businesses with 1-4 employees. The most common type of firm, representing 57% of businesses in Canada.
  • Scale: businesses with 5-19 employees and representing 30% of Canadian business.
  • Mature: businesses with 20-99 employees and representing 11% of Canadian business.”ii

I quoted Lenin in What is to be done? at the start in order to frame the discussion in terms of Marxist class analysis. This opinion is clearly not from the worker’s own interest, workers appear to have the concern of the business in mind but only as it extends to their job stability.

The other response to this argument comes from union bureaucrats who seek to minimize the contradiction between workers and their employer here. Some retorts from bureaucrats I’ve heard expressed is that unions bring about workforce stability, that union labour strengthens a business, and that over time union labour is beneficial to the business. These are terrible responses because workers have no interest needing to be allied to the well being of their capitalist’s profits. The point of a union is to leverage economic strength of negotiation and the capacity to withdraw your labour through job action in favor of workers demands. The political aspect to unionizing is the ability of workers to exert more control over being arbitrarily fired or let go, to address grievances, receive training from the union, and take collective action.

Returning to Lenin, in this position at the workplace, the communist worker should answer by separating out the fear of job stability from the desire of the bourgeoisie. Ultimately, if the small business folds, it is no different for workers to go find another business to work for, probably for comparable work conditions and pay. For the workers, little will change. If the union organizes successfully and wins the demands of the workers, there is a lot more to be gained for the workers. The communist worker should be organizing and introducing Marxism in order to increase class consciousness to workers so that they are more confident in organizing themselves at work.

ihttps://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1901/witbd/ii.htm

iihttps://chamber.ca/unveiling-the-portrait-of-small-businesses-in-canada-insights-and-challenges/