The People's Hammer

Interview with Fred Engst by the People’s Hammer Editorial Board Part 3

,


Q: You mentioned a lot real power, worker power over management you’ve mentioned, and you’ve mentioned this process of complaining against the leadership. Could you summarize for us how the GPCR advanced communism in China?

A: You see what happened is that Marx studied the contradictions in capitalist society and found out the only way to overcome this contradiction is through communist revolution. But how you do that he didn’t have time or the time was not right for it. Lenin figured out how to do that how the working class can overthrow capitalism and establish socialism. The key is you need a vanguard of working class, you cannot just be a loose canon fighting by yourself, and secondly is how to take advantage of the imperialist war in order to change the imperialist war into a civil war and how the working class can take advantage of that. But how to build socialism once you have control is a totally new situation that Marx had no opportunity to do or even to think about it. Marx is very precise, if history does not show he doesn’t speculate. He only goes by what logic and history shows so he didn’t say what dictatorship of the proletariat was like until the Paris Commune. He was very much a thorough dialectical materialist. Lenin didn’t have a chance to study this issue and Stalin stumbled on this. In retrospect he struggled against all of these capitalist roaders but he himself was not as sharp so he made a lot of mistakes in the process.

So Mao was facing this situation in 1956 when the agriculture was all pretty much collectivized and all industry in the city became state run, so basically you have a socialist economic base and theres no longer a market economy and no longer a capitalist or landlord running the economy, so then what do we do next? What are the new contradictions? What does socialism mean, what kind of socialism are we building? Then you find out in reality there’s all kinds of contradictions. How to run the economy? Do you rely on the people, or experts? Of course they all believe in a planned economy but what’s the priority? Do you put priority in heavy industry, light industry, or agriculture? And all kinds of policy issues have consequences. Consequences in terms of speed of economic development, and the relationship under production, the relationship between the leaders and the people being led, and the relationship between peasants, workers, and all kinds of issues need to be addressed. It’s something no one charted into too much from the Soviet Union, but they found lots of things to learn from the Soviet Union don’t look right. Incentive systems, the hierarchy in the planned economy, and all kinds of things that feels not quite right.

What’s wrong and what to do, you have to explore by yourself. I think the key turning point is 1957, this is after Prague spring, Polish workers’ uprising, so there was a lot of disgruntlement in China, some peasants were not happy with the leadership, some workers were not happy with leadership, some students were protesting. A lot of contradictions arise and how do you address these questions?

There are two different approaches. Mao started going around the country trying to convince the leadership from all different provinces and cities that when workers and peasants complain and criticize, don’t treat them as enemies. The upheaval of the early revolution that’s pretty much over, now it’s about how to correctly handle the contradictions among the people. That’s one approach but many others in the leadership that thought that all the riots and strikes and actions against the government were all saboteurs. It’s an infiltration, its the spies and enemies against the new government. They treated it very hostile.

Mao’s idea was that the reason people go on strike and the reason students go protest is because a lot of leadership has a very very bureaucratic style of leadership. So we need to have a rectification and try to overcome the cadre who are divorced from the masses. So he was pushing for a rectification campaign but the party bureaucracy upper level was not enthusiastic at all. So they used some of these rightists who are against socialism and communism they said “well you were in power for 8 years its time for us to have multi party elections and that kind of stuff” So some of the leadership took advantage of these right wing attack at the party and changed the whole movement into an anti-rightist campaign.

So we have such a contrast we have earlier Hundred Flower campaign and rectification campaign all of a sudden flip flopped into an anti-rightist campaign. I think in retrospect that was the first real battle between Mao and the capitalist roaders, but Mao was not clear what it was about. He was a minority and he was overruled because of democratic centralism and he was hit on the head, he didn’t know what happened.

Then there was the Great Leap Forward and the Lushan meeting in 1959 and a lot of quarreling between people in the leadership, power struggle, and so what is the nature, what is going on? He [Mao] tried all kinds of ways to figure out what’s going on. I think it took three years of famine and then after 1962 in the spring they have the thousand cadres meeting in order to summarize what happened, how did it happen, and so you find out these people in the leadership who opposed collectivization in the 50’s and then they find out after collectivization it was so easy to get grain from the peasants that they went overboard. They start having these, communist win they call it, this attitude of “we’re going to go into communism right away” which really destroyed the peasants’ enthusiasm. Then they start boasting and lying about production quotas and then trying to get more grain from the peasants. There was a lot of need to industrialize quickly and they had soviet aid for 150 some projects and they need to hire workers to start these projects, the workers need grain, and the grain can only come from peasants. So that’s the background but the method they used was just fascist, incredible. So that’s what caused the famine and destruction and everything, and on top of that it there was the Sino-Soviet Split and the Soviet Union pulled away their aid and everything. For sure there were natural disasters but the hardest hit famine areas were not the hardest hit by the natural disasters, so there was the human factor. These people made a big blunder, they boasted about production, they lied about production and so after the ‘62 meeting summarized the experience the top leaders in politburo the majority of them thought that we should not have collectivization, we should go back to individual farming. That’s why Mao, I think, finally realized what was the issue. Because the real issue was are we going down the socialist road or the capitalist road? If when we face the most difficult time, your guys’ solution is to privatize, then why do we need socialism? The reason we want socialism is because it’s the best way, the fastest way to develop economy. The productive forces become so strong and it’s evident by the Chinese statistics. The socialist period had the fastest growth of just about everything.

Mao realized the divisions he had with many people in top leadership is about whether or not to build socialism. He pushed for a socialist education campaign and to teach people never to forget about class struggle. These people in the party, later on proven to be capitalist roaders, when you ask them to lead the movement going to socialist education they do it their way which is to focus on embezzlement rather than focusing on whether you empower the masses, do you rely on the masses to do work​? I mean when you focus on embezzlement you totally miss the point. I’m not saying embezzlement is a good thing but that’s not the point.

The point is whether the person leading the factory, leading the province, do they push for socialist means or capitalist means? The difference is the capitalist way is thinking the workers naturally want to slack off so how do you incentivize the workers? Give them bonuses. It’s so telling, on one hand Marx talks about in Critique of Gotha Programme that the first stage of socialism is to each according to their work, but what does that mean to each according to his work? When you have a bonus system what it does is it makes workers become treated as a hired hand. Because if people in leadership can decide who gets the bonus, because when you get a bonus you’ve got to have some kind of standard, some kind of measurement, someone has to decide who gets the bonus, and if you let the workers decide they overwhelmingly believe in egalitarianism even though you don’t work as hard as another one, if you ask workers to divide a bonus overwhelmingly they will divide so we all get the same. If you ask the leadership to divide the bonus, then you realize if you criticize leadership they can take your bonus away. So you are no longer the master of society. That’s why the bonus system is poisonous. It strips workers’ ability to be masters of society.

The incentive system, how do you incentivize the workers? Its not just by material incentives. For example, in the discussion we had in the 70’s about who gets promoted, what it shows is that if someone is working hard, being recognized by others eventually they will get a raise. Its not like everybody no matter what they do are the same, its still each according to their work. If you work hard you will be recognized but its not like every day every second its piece work. So people when they feel like they are masters of society their enthusiasm is unbounded, its incredible. I saw how workers in our factory when they feel like they’re the masters they have all kinds of ideas how to do better, and they care. Same thing with the workers in the US, workers care about their product. They don’t like to do a shitty job, they want to do a good job, but they don’t want to do it because “faster! You have to work faster!” If I want to hike a mountain I want to go by my pace, if somebody says “go faster! Faster!” I’d say screw you.

So how to mobilize the people? How to promote production? It makes a difference whether you are taking the capitalist approach or socialist approach. Whether you allow workers, peasants, to be the masters, or you treat them as hired hands. You can see the people leading the socialist education campaign, I talked about how on the farm they had the whole thing where they were so strict with every cadre and every person being guilty until proven innocent. Look like they are so revolutionary. But actually it totally diverts the real issue. We evaluate people’s personal leadership not by whether the person embezzled or not, its about whether they empower the masses or actually treating the masses as hired hands. Do you mobilize and rely on the people, that’s the key.

The socialist education campaign didn’t do what it was hoping to do so Mao had to figure something else out. Mao really had the pulse of the people, why do I say that? Because when the Cultural Revolution began the response by the masses was enormous. The Red Guard movement spread like wildfire. Why was he able to do it? Because it touched people’s heart. Same way as what happened in the Cultural Revolution in the factories and farms. Because you empower the workers and peasants then they have incredible enthusiasm. You know because everybody likes to have a say about how their life is going. For good or for bad they like to have a say. That’s why the Cultural Revolution was so empowering in so many different aspects. The lasting impact is incredible because China came from a very feudal society. Land reform stripped some of that, collectivization overcome some of that, but the Cultural Revolution is so powerful in very few short years feudalism was totally dead. They want to restore some of that stuff so what you see in today’s China is not feudalism it’s capitalism. The capitalism, how should I describe it, is very different from the West and the people’s attitude is so different too.

Q: I wanted to ask, in Canada many do think that China is still socialist or attempting to achieve it. I’m really curious about your perspective since you came back to China you said in 2007. How would you answer the question if China is still socialist?

A: How do we define socialism? I think that’s the key. Once we clarify what we mean by socialism then maybe the answer would be more clear. There are all kinds of definitions of socialism. I think probably the most widespread is that government has a strong role in the market economy. European social democrats, Sanders in the US, they call it socialist because it means you cannot have laissez faire you need some regulation and control not to let the business do anything they want. So that’s one definition of socialism. Most of the countries in the world either they have their name has socialism or their party has socialism or some kind of social. Social democracy I think is a widespread ideology in the world.

That’s not the socialism that Marx and Lenin were talking about, or Mao talking about. If you’re saying socialism, in a Marxist sense, true Marxist sense, some social democrats also say they are Marxist but they’ve revised some incorrect or some outdated idea of Marx. Revisionists right. But true Marxism in spirit is the dictatorship of the proletariat. It has to have the working class as the ruling class. So this cannot be just in name. If one class is in power then then the economy must run according to the interests of the working class as a whole. The only way to do that is a planned economy. Planned economy is a necessary condition, not sufficient, but necessary condition for the working class to be in power. Otherwise, the working class is not in power. It can’t, it’s not possible. Because market economy by definition, you see market socialism, market economy, the people who trade the buyers and sellers both sides care about their own interests. Neither side ever cares about the interests of the people as a whole. That’s the nature of the market. If people in the market think of the overall needs there won’t be market it would be planned. The whole idea of market socialism is a contradiction in term. Unless your definition of socialism is that government has a heavy hand in the market. What you mean is that the market cannot run by any way they want but heavy regulations, in terms of labour standards, in terms of environmental protections, in terms of social welfare, that kind of stuff. That’s what they mean by market socialism. But that’s not the working class in power, it can’t.

To be in a Marxist sense of a socialist state it has to be planned economy. But planned economy doesn’t guarantee working class power because capitalist during crisis can plan the economy. Another example is the Soviet Union imploding because what we see in the Soviet Union before the Soviet Union collapsed and after the ruling class is the same. The army did not change, the elite are still the elite but they changed the way they organize the economy. And so you tell me that before the collapse and after the collapse the society is totally different? That doesn’t make any sense. And the ruling class is the same so people think that before the Soviet Union collapsed and afterwards are a totally different animal, that’s like saying flies and maggots are different animals. Because one can fly and one swims in stool. But they have the same DNA. So before soviet collapse and afterwards the DNA stayed the same. Just the way they organized was different. So they decided what to do. You can see after the collapse and implosion of the Soviet Union, Russia is a market economy, it’s capitalist. If you think Russia today is socialist, I don’t know, who thinks that? They don’t even claim it. So today they are capitalist and before the collapse they were capitalist but using planned economy. So you can see a planned economy is necessary but not sufficient condition for working class in power. We need to analyze history and use dialectical materialism to make sense of what’s going on rather than just using symbols, labels. Definitions come from reality. Why we have these definitions and labels is to help us understand reality. But we cannot let reality fit into our definitions. If reality doesn’t fit into the definition then something’s wrong with the definition not something wrong with the reality.

Q: You mentioned the Marxist standard of socialism is to have the working class in power. What is the state of the Chinese working class? Are they in power in any sense? And how is struggle happening in China?

A: I still live here so I’m not free to talk. There’s a saying that rabbits don’t eat the grass around the rabbit hole. 兔子不吃窝边草. In China the working class is the 弱势群体 – it means the underprivileged class and indeed it is glaring in your face. If you really believe in Marxism and dialectical materialism any label, any claim needs to be backed with the facts not just opinion. How do we tell working class in power or not? You cannot just go by“they say so.”When I came back a lot of people said the working class was never in power in China. I said well that doesn’t feel right, but what’s wrong with it? They provided evidence that all the people in leadership came from landlord class and capitalists and elite class so that’s why the working class was never in power. I said well following that logic the working class is often in power in England because they have the Labour Party in power. That logic doesn’t work. The Labour Party is imperialist, so you cannot go by the background of the people in the party leadership to determine whether a Party is working class or capitalist.

So then how do we prove that Mao’s period the working class was in power? Of course I believe that but I need the evidence. So I was studying what happened in the Cultural Revolution and one day all of a sudden it hit me. If working class was not in power, how can you have violent clashes between different factions in the factories? When you have a civil war, at least one side must be the ruling class. In history you never see a civil war between non-ruling class. You have either like the US civil war between the slave owners and the northern industrialists or the Chinese civil war between nationalists and communists. At least one class has to be the ruling class, you cannot have neither side be the ruling class and a civil war. So when you have clashes in the factory among different workers, which side is the ruling class? You cannot say both are not. People say well we need democracy, well that’s what China did have. People say “well that’s not democracy the working class is not in control.” I say well imagine in a capitalist society workers factions fighting each other. The boss would pull out the machine gun. You don’t get the chance to have a civil war at all. So basically we need evidence, and the Cultural Revolution is the evidence. It hit the nail on the head, undeniable, the evidence that the working class was in power. However, factionalism caused them to lose power. But, they were in power! Demonstrated by the factional fighting. Even though factional fighting is terrible but it proved beyond any reasonable doubt that the working class was in power. Today, they are the underprivileged.

Q: What do you have to say for Canadian workers and communists?

A: Canadian workers, well pretty much the same as the US workers. I think we’ve got to thank Trump, Trump is a real great educator. Trump destroyed capitalism faster than anybody else. So many people have so many delusions about capitalism, and Trump is so blatant. In Chinese there’s a saying that 我是流氓我怕谁? – I’m a bandit and I’m not afraid of anybody because I’m the bandit.

Q: We have a unique situation in Canada where Trump is creating a nationalist, semi-fascist reaction from the Canadian not working class but mostly middle class.

A: In this case the nationalism is probably a bit better than the warship in the US. Same thing in the US, a lot of the blue collars, so called redneck, I don’t like that term but a lot of working class in the rust belt voted for Trump and they thought he would bring something better. History is repeating itself because in the 30’s German workers why they voted for the Nazis is because that’s the thing with class struggle which is that when working class are unsatisfied and unhappy with the current situation they either go to communism or fascism. They want a change. That’s why they said people in New York City who voted for Mamdani also voted for Trump. The working class can sometimes show some sympathy or believe in fascist thing but actually what you need to do is show them that those things are false alternatives, its going to hurt our struggle.

The rise of fascism actually tells me that the class struggle is intensifying because people are not happy with what’s going on. Unlike in the 80’s and 90’s it was dead, those days I was so hopeless. Today I am so happy, so energetic, because we see the contradictions really rising and Marxism has been validated, MLM is being validated, and we see all around the world people getting more and more into Marxism. Same thing we’re seeing in China the young people are all of a sudden rediscovering Marx and Mao and rediscovering the early history. When I do this social media I get an overwhelming response totally out of my expectation. I never thought there would be that type of response. When I talk about my own experience in the West and working in a Chinese factory, comparing the two societies, and also using Marxist analysis to address current issues they find it very enlightening and very interesting. They say this is what Marxism is! I didn’t say anything new, I’m just an old fossil from the old days and they find it fascinating. 20 years ago people thought I’m just an old relic, an old person reminiscing on the greatness of their childhood. They thought I was just reliving my memory. When I use that approach to analyze contemporary society, US or China, people find that enlightening.