Mediation according to the BC Labour Board is supposed to provide a “neutral” third party from the labour board to move along collective bargaining.i According to section 74 of the BC Labour Code, a mediator can be appointed if either one of the two parties apply for one, or if the minister of labour assigns one to the workplace during negotiations.ii Currently, to end the process either one of the parties has to ask for the mediator to “report out” which involves the mediator writing a report with their experience in mediating including their suggestions and conclusions over how the remaining bargaining items should be discussed. In the next division, the Labour Code spells out other stipulations around mediation: including the right for an employer or union to call a vote on the latest offer before a strike or lockout in order to keep the job action at bay, as well as the minister’s power given the situation that “the minister considers that it is in the public interest” to call a vote during a strike or lockout for workers to accept or reject the latest offer. These in particular are hurdles for not only workers to organize into effective job actions, but also undermines any independence that workers in unions have to act and decide for themselves on their own timelines.
Compounding onto this, there exists section 55 which is specific to first contract negotiations. In this case, the mediator can remove the worker’s right to strike:
“If the first collective agreement is not concluded within 20 days of the appointment of the mediator, the mediator must report to the associate chair and recommend either or both of the following:
(a) the terms of the first collective agreement for consideration by the parties;
(b) a process for concluding the first collective agreement including one or more of the following:
(i) further mediation by a person empowered to arbitrate any issues not resolved by agreement and to conclude the terms of the first collective agreement;
(ii) arbitration by a single arbitrator or by the board, to conclude the terms of the first collective agreement;
(iii) allowing the parties to exercise their rights under this Code to strike or lock out.”iii
Then,
“If the associate chair directs a method set out in subsection (6) (b) (i) or (ii), the parties must refrain from or cease any strike or lockout activity, and the terms of the collective agreement recommended or concluded under that subsection are binding on the parties [my emphasis].”iv
Simply put, for the sake of timeliness alone, the mediator can put to arbitration the rest of the contract and completely undermine worker’s rights to strike once the contract is in mediation.
My coworkers and I are in first contract negotiations for a year now. We’ve bargained on our own for the first half, and upon repeated efforts from the employer in stalling we entered into mediation. Some coworkers were excited that this will effectively speed up the negotiations, and that the employer wouldn’t be able to play their games in delaying or maneuvering around the bargaining procedure. However, almost another half a year later we have not made much movement with the “help” of mediation. Furthermore, the mediator has taken it upon themselves to guard the employer on several fronts when they are required to provide documentation and proof of their claims. What has been effective in this experience has been the participation of the workers alongside the Workers United Front in coordinating several pressure campaigns on the employer. Each time a stride has been taken forward has been the result of the WUF local working alongside the workers to further our own objectives, and not tailing behind union bureaucracy or the labour board.
What we can understand from the labour code and the practical experience is that the Labour Board operates as a bureaucratic wing of the state bourgeoisie. Working side by side, the state bourgeoisie protects private business bourgeoisie by diverting organized workers’ efforts into a long legal struggle. Often, unions will disagree with the rulings of a mediator or arbitration, but be forced to follow the ruling and their only recourse is to file appeals to the same labour board that sent them back to work. Other times, unions will threaten companies with Unfair Labour Practices (a legal procedure through the labour board) in hopes of reprimanding the employer for their behaviours, or at least discouraging them from further bad behaviour. But in all this we see the cycle that derails workers from using their full capacity to enact job action (strike, work slow down, etc) and distinguishes this momentum into a legal process that is so bureaucratic that you need a handle on law and the labour code to deal with. Mediators, who are framed as “neutral” parties, and who some of them even move up the ranks from labour unions themselves, are all the same agents of the state bourgeoisie. That is, they promote conciliation with businesses, diversion of worker’s action towards the bureaucratic legal process, and can even reprimand workers if they feel that their actions have been out of line with the status quo of the bargaining process even if those actions are well within their legal rights. Finally, the process to exit mediation is itself punitive to workers. When you are under first contract negotiation, the mediator can effectively take your right to strike away and force you to be helpless in front of your boss and accept what little is offered through these “final offers.”
Communists and workers must break out of this cycle and refuse mediation and the bureaucratic legal process. Workers who have a growing class consciousness are discouraged and abandon struggle when the attention turns to this. It is not a surprise but a reasonable outcome when you hand the reigns of your workplace to a bureaucrat who says they’re going to deal with it through the legal process. Instead, we must engage our coworkers to their fullest and direct their anger towards struggling actively against repression and maneuvering from the employer.
ihttps://www.lrb.bc.ca/collective-bargaining-mediation
iihttps://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96244_01#section74
iiihttps://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96244_01#section55
ivhttps://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96244_01#section55