The People's Hammer

Chief Dsta’hyl found guilty of criminal contempt by B.C. Supreme Court – by Kale



The tireless efforts of Indigenous nations seeking self-determination and resisting colonial structures have once again collided with the power of Canadian courts. Recent developments in the Wet’suwet’en territorial dispute highlight the urgent need for solidarity and allyship in the fight against colonization and exploitation.

British Columbia Supreme Court recently convicted Chief Dsta’hyl, a Wing Chief of the Likhs’amisyu Clan of the Wet’suwet’en Nation, of criminal contempt due to his violation of an injunction granted to Coastal GasLink. This ruling came after considering whether a traditional Wet’suwet’en trespass law could coexist with the court order.1

Wet’suwet’en hereditary leaders have long opposed pipeline construction through their traditional territory. Following failed negotiations, the B.C. Supreme Court granted a permanent injunction to Coastal GasLink (CGL) in late 2019, leading to confrontations between the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) and Wet’suwet’en land protectors. Despite this, Coastal GasLink declared mechanical completion of the pipeline in November 2021, citing agreements with five out of six Wet’suwet’en band councils as proof of backing for the initiative. However, it is crucial to note that while the band councils were established as a colonial institution and hold authority solely over limited reservation territories. The hereditary leaders, according to traditional governance practices, maintain control over the unsettled Wet’suwet’en lands where the pipeline path lies.

Since January 2019, there have been over 75 arrests under the injunction, including that of Chief Dsta’hyl in October 2021. Recently, three Indigenous land defenders – Sleydo’ Molly Wickham, Shaylynn Sampson, and Corey Jocko – were convicted of criminal contempt following their arrest in November 2021. Meanwhile, hearings are being held to determine if the charges against them should be stayed based on alleged police misconduct during the arrests.

Chief Dsta’hyl was arrested following several encounters with Coastal Gaslink personnel and security agents along the Shea Forest Service Road within the jurisdiction of the Likhts’amisyu Clan. These exchanges involved preventing access to job site and disabling various CGL contractor machines by cutting electrical wires and taking out batteries. At the time of his apprehension, the chief had four construction machine batteries inside his vehicle, as per the ruling. Judge Tammen stated there were no disagreements regarding these fundamental details, pointing out videotaped documentation depicting the events. Specifically referencing October 17th, 2021, the judge mentioned how Chief Dsta’hyl, performing duties as an enforcer for the Likhts’amisyu Clan, removed a battery from a CGL subcontractor’s excavation device, effectively immobilizing it.

Defence witnesses, who were fellow Likhts’amisyu Chiefs, spoke about the Wet’suwet’en traditional clan system and its function in managing the traditional land, known as “yintah”. They emphasized the duty of Chiefs to maintain and safeguard their territory. Tammen explained the Wet’suwet’en concept of trespass, stating that explicit consent is necessary to enter land owned by a house group, extending beyond mere transit. Historically, severe consequences like shooting and killing followed repeated violations of territorial boundaries. Although such measures are no longer practiced today, the significance of trespassing remains substantial.

The defense argued that seizing or disabling heavy equipment was a justified tactic to pressure CGL into dialogue with the Hereditary Chiefs, aligning with Wet’suwet’en law. Knowing his actions violated the injunction, Chief Dsta’hyl maintained he was upholding Wet’suwet’en law and was transparent with law enforcement. However, Judge Tammen claimed to find ample evidence indicating Dsta’hyl aimed to undermine the court’s authority, citing derogatory remarks towards to judiciary such as “Dishonourable Church” and “Injustice Church”. He also referred to several remarks by Chief Dsta’hyl in which he correctly pointed out that “your law doesn’t work on our territory” and that the injunction was “invalid”. The judge dismissed the defense’s argument, stating that previous legal avenues were available for addressing grievances. Consequently, Dsta’hyl was found guilty of criminal contempt for daring to question the colonial authorities, with sentencing scheduled for March 6 2024.

Whereas even the imperialist Unite Nations emphasizes free, prior, and informed consent for projects affecting Indigenous peoples in its Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), Canada’s legal apparatus continues to silence and suppress resistance movements. By dismissing the potential for coexistence between distinct legal systems, Canadian authorities perpetuate the historical marginalization of Indigenous populations.2

Canadian courts have proven time and time again that they are incapable of addressing the root causes of inequality and violence inflicted upon Indigenous communities, namely, Imperialism. Instead, they bolster resource extraction industries profiting from stolen lands, exacerbating environmental harm and the immiseration of the working class. Indigenous liberation cannot be achieved through the establishment of independent capitalist states because this approach fails to fundamentally challenge the underlying structures of capitalist-imperialism that perpetuate national oppression. Instead, it attempts to work within the existing framework of power and exploitation, risking the reproduction of similar forms of inequality and dependence on imperialist forces.

Indeed this is what has historically happened. The achievement of formal political independence did not lead to genuine economic self-determination for the ‘formerly’ colonized countries. Instead, these new states or rather semi-colonies found themselves still subordinated to their ‘former’ colonizers. These semi-colonies have the appearance of independent, self-governing entities; however, where there was once a more direct, open and explicit domination by colonial powers, in reality, they now function as subordinate components within the larger global capitalist system. Their economies are dependent upon the extraction and exportation of natural resources, with profits flowing disproportionately to advanced capitalist countries leaving them trapped in cycles of poverty and underdevelopment. Meanwhile, the ruling elites in these nations often maintain power through alliances with transnational corporations and international financial institutions, further entrenching the neocolonial relationship. In essence, despite appearances, semi-colonial societies continue to be subject to the dictates of imperialism and its attendant class dynamics.

This is due to the inherent nature of capitalism, which creates exploitative relations between countries and within them. The only way to break free from this cycle of dependency and underdevelopment is through socialist revolution. By seizing control of the means of production and establishing a planned economy based on need rather than profit, workers and peasants can begin to build an alternative society that prioritizes human well-being over profits.

Indeed, true national liberation for the Wet’suwet’en nation, like any other colonized nation, can only be achieved true socialist revolution. Only in a socialist society could the Wet’suwet’en workers exercise democratic control over their land and determine their destinies.

To this end, workers, Indigenous and Canadian alike share a common interest in joining forces to combat capitalist-imperialist exploitation. Forging genuine connections among diverse communities fighting separate yet interconnected battles strengthens our collective capacity to challenge imperialism and build a better world together.

Citations:

1. https://thetyee.ca/News/2024/02/21/Wetsuweten-Law-Cannot-Coexist-BC-Court-Order/

2. https://www.un.org/development/desa/indigenouspeoples/wp-content/uploads/sites/19/2018/11/UNDRIP_E_web.pdf


Response to “Chief Dsta’hyl found guilty of criminal contempt by B.C. Supreme Court – by Kale”

  1. Interview with a Resident of the Student Encampments for Palestine – by Michael B. – The People's Hammer

    […] I: Notably, the People’s Hammer has reported that this was tried by a Wet’suwet’en chief and it did not work. (https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/04/01/chief-dstahyl-found-guilty-of-criminal-contempt-by-b-&#8230😉 […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *