The People's Hammer

Imperialists Attempt to Resolve the Rising Cost of Food – by Daniel H.



The crisis-prone nature of imperialism has been on full display for the workers of Canada the past several years. Unemployment’s sharp peak in 2020 and its steady return today1 along with the highest inflation rate in a generation2 are only the most obvious examples. In both cases, the bourgeoisie have attempted to shift the burden of the crisis on to the backs of the workers despite it being the outcome of the mode of production they benefit from.3

The increasing price of groceries is the latest attempt of the bourgeoisie to turn the imperialist crisis into something they can benefit from at the the workers’ expense. The Centre for Future Work, a research centre focusing on labour issues, has estimated that grocers made $6 billion of profits in 2023 meaning an 8% increase since last year and a doubling of profits since before the covid-19 pandemic.4 As these numbers reflect the profits of the grocery market as a whole and not any specific grocer, these numbers cannot be written off as the growth of the market (after all who does not need to eat?). Instead they reflect the 8.3% rise in the cost of food between 2022 and 2023.5 When compared to two years prior, prices are up 20%.6

Grocery Prices and Imperialism in Canada

The grocery monopolies have pushed the blame for the high prices on supply-chain issues and the general effects of inflation. Certainly there is a considerable amount of truth to this. The fact that it is more profitable to invest in agriculture in the oppressed nations overseas than in the prairies means that when production is disrupted internationally, distribution is disrupted domestically. Similarly, while inflation has faced the entire population generally, its effects on the workers and the bourgeoisie are not equal. The big bourgeoisie especially have benefited from the Bank of Canada’s interest-rate hikes as they have 1) increased unemployment thereby decreasing the cost of labour and 2) allowed for a greater centralisation of capital as small and medium companies collapse. Today the inflation rate is at 2.9% compared to a high in 2022 of 8.1%.7 Despite this, food prices have not stabilised. So, while the inefficiencies of capitalist production play a role, it is not the whole story.

As mentioned above, we live under imperialism. This is the highest stage of capitalist production in which the free market has been centralised into a handful of monopolies whose driving force is the financial institutions. Under a free market it is only possible to sell goods on average for the value of the materials used and the labour added. If there is high demand for the product it can sell higher than this value and if the demand is low it may need to sell below it. However the average price is its value. Under imperialism one of the main expressions of monopoly is in the form of cartels which are capitalist associations that control an industry. Lenin wrote on the significance of the emergence of cartels in his Imperialism:

“Cartels come to an agreement on the terms of sale, dates of payment, etc. They divide the markets among themselves. They fix the quantity of goods to be produced. They fix prices. They divide the profits among the various enterprises, etc.(my emphasis)”8

The near-complete control of an industry by a cartel allows for them to increase the price of goods above the value produced. This is being seen in Canada today.

The grocery industry of Canada has been exposed as being run by a cartel over-and-over again. In June 2020, the largest grocers in Canada collaborated to cut the “hero pay” given to their workers at the start of the pandemic, essentially engaging in an overt wage-fixing scheme.9 In another situation it has been revealed that bakery suppliers and retailers have engaged in price-fixing around bread in Canada.10

Cartels, price-fixing, and wage-fixing are not some conspiracy. They are a very real fact of the Canadian imperialist economy.

The Response from the State

In response to popular demands, mobilisation against the increasing cost of living, pressure from the middle bourgeoisie, and in attempt to save his waning popularity, Trudeau has been forced to act on grocery prices. Trudeau’s actions have been a combination of toothless actions and pandering to the masses in the form of the Competition Act amendments and the Grocer Code of Conduct.

These amendments to the Competition Act came on December 15. The main changes were to:

  • “Create a framework for market studies with information gathering powers;
  • “Repeal the efficiencies defence for anti-competitive mergers and business collaborations;
  • “Simplify the legal test for abuse of dominance and increase the maximum penalties available; and,
  • “Expand the scope of the law to restrict more anti-competitive business collaborations.”11

While these changes make it harder for monopolies to increasingly centralise themselves, it does nothing to relieve the burden that the bourgeoisie has placed on the masses. The big bourgeoisie in the industry have not been reined-in the slightest and still fully control the industry. The effects of the act do not even come into force until December 15, 2024.12

The Liberals’ feigned anger with the increasing cost of groceries has been nothing but an attempt to deceive the workers from the start. To see this we can look over at the telecommunications industry. At the same time as the federal government were pretending to discipline the monopolies in the grocery industry, they allowed for the merger of Rogers and Shaw.13 This merger massively centralised capital in the telecommunications industry beyond its previous already highly-centralised state. Under a capitalist state the workers cannot expect the government to act against the interests of the bourgeoisie.

Grocery Industry Code of Conduct

Alongside these reforms to the Competition Act, there has been a major push for a code of conduct for the industry. The code of conduct has the backing of the middle bourgeoisie and petite-bourgeoisie in the grocery industry organised under the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers (CFIG).14 CFIG’s aim in pushing for the code of conduct is to increase their membership’s competitiveness with the big bourgeoisie by introducing new regulations.

The code of conduct has also received some backing from sections of the big bourgeoisie. This can be seen in the response of the federal government and one of the smaller monopolies, Metro. For the federal government, the code of conduct is a way for them to appear as if they are active in trying to resolve this issue that is crushing and angering the workers. Currently, the code of conduct is a voluntary document, but the House of Commons committee investigating the surge in food prices has stated they will propose making its adherence mandatory if the larger monopolies do not sign the code.15 Metro has been very active in campaigning for the code of conduct. It has claimed that it is willing to sign, but that the document would be useless unless the major monopolies are signed on as well.16 Metro has further called on them to sign the code.17 Metro’s interests align with those of CFIG on the question of the code of conduct. While Metro does dominate a large portion of the market, it is the smallest of the major Canadian companies in the industry. While Metro can claim 10.8% of the industry, Loblaws holds 29%. Among the major grocers active in Canada only Walmart controls a smaller share with 7.5%.18 Metro, like the CFIG companies, wants to increase their ability to compete by bringing in the code of conduct.

Loblaws, the largest grocery monopoly in Canada, has been the main hurdle to the enactment of the code of conduct.19 They have pleaded that a code of conduct will only lead to an increase in food prices.20 Unlike Metro and the CFIG grocers, Loblaws aims to defend its strength in the industry. What will allow the weaker corporations to better compete is directly against their interests.

The Workers’ Solution to Rising Food Prices

The only solution the bourgeoisie can offer to the problem of rising food prices is more competition. As we have already stated, however, the natural progression of competition is monopoly. This is because in the earlier free market period the larger companies ruined the smaller ones and centralised their capital. This led to the increasing domination of finance-led monopoly capitalism – imperialism. Therefore the answer to this problem is not increased competition. Should the federal government dissolve the current monopolies into several parts, new monopolies will emerge due to the natural tendency in this direction.

For the workers, the solution lies in the abolition of imperialism and the establishment of communism. With the means of distribution alongside the entire economy in the hands of the people as a whole, the economy can be planned to meet the demands of the entirety of society.

While recognising that only communism will resolve the problem absolutely, the workers must fight for a relative resolution today under imperialism. As with the monopolisation of the economy under communism, we must fight today for the increased monopolisation of the industry. This means the nationalisation of the large and medium grocers including the distribution and transportation networks they are based on. Further, the workers must demand workers’ control of the nationalised industry. This means power vested in workers committees from the bottom to the top of the industry.

Nationalisation under workers’ control will make the realisation of communism a smoother path for the workers. When the workers have reconstituted their communist party and have begun to set up their workers’ republic, they will confiscate this nationalised industry. In doing so, the industry will pass from the domain of bourgeois ownership into the hands of the working-class administered through their state. This change will mark the beginning of the transition to communism.

  1. https://tradingeconomics.com/canada/unemployment-rate
  2. https://tradingeconomics.com/canada/inflation-cpi
  3. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/05/01/the-proletariat-will-not-pay-for-the-imperialist-crisis/
  4. https://vancouver.citynews.ca/2023/12/12/canada-grocery-industry-record-profits/
  5. https://thevarsity.ca/2023/10/29/why-canada-is-taking-regulatory-action-against-your-local-grocery-chain/
  6. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/metro-ceo-agriculture-committee-1.7055831
  7. https://tradingeconomics.com/canada/inflation-cpi
  8. https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1916/imp-hsc/ch01.htm
  9. https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/10/30/support-sobeys-workers-against-union-busting/
  10. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/canada-bread-price-fixing-1.7053066
  11. https://www.canada.ca/en/competition-bureau/news/2023/12/important-amendments-to-modernize-the-competition-act-receive-royal-assent.html
  12. https://www.canada.ca/en/competition-bureau/news/2023/12/important-amendments-to-modernize-the-competition-act-receive-royal-assent.html
  13. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/rogers-shaw-merger-official-1.6799566
  14. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/grocery-prices-loblaws-walmart-1.7051931
  15. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/grocery-code-of-conduct-loblaw-walmart-1.7118261
  16. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/grocery-code-of-conduct-loblaw-walmart-1.7118261
  17. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/metro-ceo-agriculture-committee-1.7055831
  18. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/grocery-prices-loblaws-walmart-1.7051931
  19. https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/grocery-code-of-conduct-loblaw-walmart-1.7118261
  20. https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/grocery-prices-loblaws-walmart-1.7051931

Response to “Imperialists Attempt to Resolve the Rising Cost of Food – by Daniel H.”

  1. Postmedia Acquisition of Saltwire – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *