The People's Hammer

Automotive Worker Speaks on Industry, Unions, and Firing – by Daniel H.

,


Question:

What industry do you work in?

Answer:

I work as a mechanic. Generally I work within the automotive industry. There are quite a few jobs in the automotive industry. A mechanic is just one of them, but its probably the most common.

Question:

Where do you work?

Answer:

I worked at Alliance Mobility.

Question:

What were the conditions like at Alliance Mobility?

Answer:

The conditions were quite bad. Everyone, including myself, were getting paid very little. Basically the same as entry-level positions at non-skill jobs despite the job requiring quite a bit of skill, knowledge, and experience.

We had no benefits, very little holiday, the minimum legal sick days. Our bosses were often quite toxic, yelling at employees and zero respect. It was also very much an atmosphere of do it “quick and dirty” which most of the mechanics – all of the mechanics – did not want to do. We wanted to do the best we could because we are proud of our work, but they only cared about the bottom dollar. If it took an extra hour to replace a part properly, they would rather just kick it out the door.

Question:

You said you were not being paid much above what an entry-level unskilled job would pay. Would that mean $19 or $20$ per hour? [The current minimum wage in British Columbia is $16.75 per hour]

Answer:

I started at $18, then got bumped up to $19. Most of the other guys were making in between I think $25 to $30 per hour max. In the industry, you’re easily making $5 to $10 more than that.

Question:

You mentioned the “quick and dirty” approach to work. How did this effect your work?

Answer:

It led to lots of the manager yelling at us because sometimes we wouldn’t listen and we would do it the proper way, but then they’re yelling at us like:

“Why isn’t this out the door?” Or, “Why is it taking longer?”

Question:

You’ve already mentioned that the wages were lower than other shops in the same industry. Do you know how the conditions you spoke about differ from those other shops?

Answer:

It’s entirely dependent on each shop, I think. Especially in these smaller shops. Basically, people need work these days and don’t have a lot of options so they’re being pushed out into these worse situations even though there are shops that can pay quite a bit better and give you benefits and can put you through school. The lack of consistency across the industry is pushing the standards down.

Question:

Regardless of these differences between shops, are there common concerns that you have noticed unite workers across the industry which they can be mobilised around?

Answer:

I would say safety is a big one. A part of the “quick and dirty” process is avoiding safety protocols and if it feels sketchy you just do it anyway and get it done.

Other than that, I would say stability as well. These places tend to have a lot of high turn-over. It doesn’t matter how well you do your job because if they have a better guy come in then you’re gone. They won’t move you up or train you at a lot of these places – some will, but a lot won’t.

So, stability and safety I think are the two main demands. Also, just enough money to live. The mechanics that have gone through their apprenticeships and are Red Seal don’t really have that issue. They get paid decently compared to other jobs, but the mechanics that are just starting out – pre-apprentices and first or second year apprentices are basically tied to whatever the boss tells you. They are treated as disposable.

Question:

Does this led to competition between workers in the industry?

Answer:

I have seen it, but would say less so in my most recent experience. When you get to some of the higher Red Seal guys, they like to claim their work like:

“I do these jobs. No one else does these jobs.”

Which is silly. At the end of the day they would also benefit from a struggle against the boss rather than against each other. I think there is a lot of solidarity as well between the lower rungs and even the upper rungs. At the end of the day they want to make sure that they’re doing good work, everyone is doing good work, and everyone’s being compensated fairly.

Question:

When I asked early where you work, you said you “worked”at Alliance Mobility. Do you want to explain why you don’t work there anymore?

Answer:

I was unexpectedly fired out of the blue. They had previously no issue with my work. I was following the instructions of the technician that was training me. They did not like his instructions, but rather than sort it out in a diplomatic manner or talking to him, it all just fell on to me and I was out the door in a matter of minutes.

I was also at the time trying to unionise the place. I am still not 100% sure that that led to my firing, but I have a feeling it did because it was so sudden.

When I did bring up the question, for legal reasons, of whether or not that was the reason they fired me, they were very displeased with it. They were definitely scared of having a union in the place or even having union talk in the place.

At the end of the day, I think that is the benefit of a union is that it can help you avoid this sort of thing. If you have a union, they can’t just fire you out of the blue. They have to go through the process of making sure that you’re doing your work. But if you’re doing your work, then the union can back you up.

Question:

Within the automotive industry in B.C., generally, are there a lot of unions present? Or is most work done in non-union shops?

Answer:

Almost all non-union. I can’t name one. I can name a few shops that have tried to unionise and the bosses shut it down. It is definitely lacking – actually that’s incorrect. The Vancouver bus company’s mechanics. I think their unionisation, despite being a relatively small amount of workers, has helped out non-union workers a lot by driving up the expectations of what the benefits of the job could be.

Question:

Despite all that, could you speak to which unions are present in the industry? You were working to unionise Alliance Mobility, were you working with any union in particular?

Answer:

I reached out to the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers. They were quite receptive and willing to help me out quite quickly before I got fired. After I got fired, they were still willing to help me out.

Question:

By the time you were fired were your coworkers supportive of the union effort? What was their response?

Answer:

Generally, yes. I had gotten the majority of my coworkers onboard or at least interested. The union really answered a lot of questions they had in terms of the struggles they faced in the workplace like wages, no benefits, and the atmosphere of the managers, the “quick and dirty” attitude, and being disrespectful to the workers

Question:

Would you be able to speak more about the structure of the workplace?

Answer:

With regards to the manager, there were some more senior guys who could get away with talking back occasionally or trying to negotiate on their own behalf.

There were also quite a few workers who were just starting out who were singled out by management who basically had no voice and couldn’t negotiate on their behalf or talk back because they would be instantly fired like I was even though I didn’t talk back.

I think that’s another benefit of the union because rather than focusing on your individual seniority, you would build up your workplace and help everyone out. You may be able to negotiate with your boss, but there could be half of your workplace that can’t.

Question:

Have you gone to trade school or gotten certified in your trade?

Answer:

No, I haven’t gone to trade school. I’m just starting out in the industry, trying to get my foot in.

Question:

Were the other workers you were talking about who could negotiate on their own more certified or skilled workers compared to those you said could be more readily fired?

Answer:

Yeah. I don’t think they had any specific certifications. This place was weird. No one was really certified except the manager – except for maybe one. But they had been in the industry for 20 plus years, so they had accrued the experience.

Question:

At one end of the automotive industry where the cars are actually manufactured it appears to be highly unionised. There is the UAW [United Auto Workers] in Windsor and down south as well as Unifor. Further down the line in maintenance and post-production additions to the car there is a lack of unions.

Answer:

Yeah, for sure.

Question:

How do you see the prospects for industrial unionism in your industry?

Answer:

I definitely think there’s prospects. I think there is a demand for better conditions across the automotive industry. Even the people who are unionised are constantly having to fight the companies to keep their standard of life. The guys that are further up have taken up a more individualist negotiation process. But, like I said that doesn’t work for a lot of people – for most people. I think having the union spread out and take control of every aspect of these companies would give the workers power over their destiny rather than have that in the hands of the companies.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *